Every week The Herald's restaurant reviewer samples some of the best - or possibly worst - eateries in the country.
You can read his review in print and online every Saturday - or two days early if you sign up to our newsletter.
Here are 10 of his most recent reviews, from best to worst.
Haylynn Canteen, 996 Dumbarton Road, Glasgow
"They’re hot, buttery, puffy and while I enjoy probably a piece or two more than is strictly necessary for research purposes I’ve got the message. Haylynn canteen: Good stuff."
-
Menu: Interesting and not very canteeny: chorizo, corn potato hash and manchego; chicken schnitzel - stuff you may want to try. 5/5
-
Service: Faultless: chatty, relaxed and welcoming. 5/5
-
Atmosphere: They’ve gone for an actual old school actual canteen vibe, and put the pizzaz into the cooking. 4/5
-
Price: Boiled egg and soldiers is £4, the Merguez £13, while the schnitzel and girolles topped the price list at £15. 3/5
-
Food: Cooking to a very high standard; food carefully prepared and freshly presented: the schnitzel was a pleasure to eat. 8/10
-
Total: 25/30
Sole Club, 1132 Argyle Street, Glasgow
"As in all the children of Six By Nico restaurants I’ve been to over the years, and I can tire of their constant reinvention, the commitment to highly professional presentation does not mean they forget the stuff’s still gotta taste good."
-
Menu: It’s a fishy theme: oysters 'n’ hot sauce; proper Thai fish cakes, risotto, blackened Coley. Interesting. 4/5
-
Atmosphere: Money’s been spent and it shows with leathery booths, spotlighted art and a seductive, clubby atmosphere. 4/5
-
Service: There were a few awkward moments at the start then…clickety-click, the food started coming and it gelled perfectly. 4/5
-
Price: At £25 a head for four intriguing courses, a total bargain, And they did not charge for the un-chilled water. Bonus point. 5/5
-
Food: They can make something as ordinary as a fishcake seem special, fresh oysters, even some quality Coley. 8/10
-
Total: 25/30
La Bodega, 98 Bellgrove Street, Glasgow
La Bodega, Glasgow (Image: free)
"This may be my most surprising food of the year. It looks like a sandwich made of French toast, but it’s not French Toast because it’s er not toast at all. And it has the imprint of mashed, flattened, crisped and toasted plantain imprinted upon it. Actually, not toasted. Fried twice."
-
Menu: Empanadas, canoas, capachas and the Papelon: Venezuelan street food in a Dennistoun cafe. High fives all round. 5/5
-
Service: Relaxed, friendly counter service in what North Americans would call a Mom and Pop cafe. 4/5
-
Atmosphere: It’s a warm homespun place with only a hint of its culinary roots, comfortable enough 3/5
-
Price: Empanadas from £2.70 up to £2.95, Patacon £5.95, that Reina Pepiada just £4. Big bargain territory. 5/5
-
Food: That Patecon was the surprise sandwich of the year. The empanadas and arepas pan-fresh with all the benefits that brings. 8/10
-
Total: 25/30
Brett, 321 Great Western Road, Glasgow
"Magnificent slabs of steak forked on the gas-charcoal grill, smoke rising, flames crackling, plates being plated, juicy aromas going barrelling by, oui-chefs pinging to and fro, it’s an eat-o-rama-plus. This is the kitchen of The Bear come to life surely, I think."
-
Menu: Chicken wings and surf clams in Scotch Bonnet Sauce, Beetroot and Blackberry, Duck and Broad Beans; interesting stuff. 4/5
-
Service: I sat at the counter facing the open kitchen and enjoyed the very professional cheffy show, nice, hard-working guys too 5/5
-
Atmosphere: This is their secret sauce; great buzz from that kitchen, low ceilinged intimate feel, with a view onto Great Western Road. Liked it. 5/5
-
Price: I ordered no sides, a mistake which does make the meal seem pretty light. Not cheap but high quality. Starters £12 to £17, mains £23 to £38, two course set: £28. 3/5
-
Food: This meal was enhanced by the atmosphere and vibe. The chicken wings and surf clams were a stand-out and the simple duck and beans almost perfect. 8/10
-
Total: 25/30
Salandini’s, 49 Hyndland Street, Glasgow
"This is fantastic; hot, silkier than a George Best chat up line, flavour clinging to every light strand. Fresh pasta is all about mouth feel, and with the hunks of glistening, seared Italian sausage, this is mouth-feel-o-rama."
-
Menu: Handmaking pasta joint with pappardelles, raviolis and mezzalunes. Next door to Nowita’s handmade ice creams too. 4/5
-
Service: They’re mainly about the takeaway pasta but if you sit in they’re pleasant and helpful, if very busy. 4/5
-
Atmosphere: Good, if you like the vibe from a bustling pastificio and don’t mind sitting at a pavement table and the sun is shining. 4/5
-
Price: Their most expensive pasta is £4.50, the sauces only run to £6 max. Great value. 5/5
-
Food: If you pick the right sauce with the right pasta, as I did half the time, this is lovely stuff with that magical mouth-feel. 8/10
-
Total: 25/30
Dennistoun Bar-b-que, 585 Duke Street, Glasgow
"The Dennistoun still does one thing few other places can do in Scotland, but everyone can do on the continent: make good chips. Fried, maybe twice, probably from frozen but so what, hot, salty golden, thin and sprawling across that greaseproof covered tray."
-
Menu: half racks of ribs, BBQ brisket sides, burgers, fries but not from the back of a freezer food van 4/5
-
Atmosphere: It’s definitely got atmosphere. On a languid Sunday afternoon, it’s a bit black and low rent and weary feeling but that’s deliberate isn’t it? 3/5
-
Service: Like the atmosphere, it’s hard to tell if it’s part of the package. Sometimes too cool for skool, but hands off and they’re going to be annoying anyone with over-friendly chat. 3/5
-
Price: Racks of ribs a tenner, tubs of brisket a fiver, burgers hitting £10 too. I think for hand-knitted stuff that’s pretty good. 5/5
-
Food: They do great brisket, excellent own-smoked ribs and even their fries are way better than average. Burger needs a grown up bun but overall: 8/10
-
Total: 23/30
The Olive Tree, Savoy Centre, 140 Sauchiehall Street, Glasgow
"The food? Yep. It’s good. The fried rice when it arrives still steaming and slightly smoky from the wok is light, moist and chunked with chicken, little salt bursts coming from micro (almost invisible) pieces of fish that turn out to be not nearly as scary as they seem on the menu."
-
Menu: They’ve got two. Ask for the secret Chinese food one. Good range of interesting and slightly different dishes including chicken and salt fish fried rice, woozy dumplings and fritters. 4/5
-
Service: Remember it’s a cash-only operation and you won’t have any problem. The waitresses, pleasant and helpful. 4/5
-
Atmosphere: Come on, it’s The Savoy Centre at lunchtime. No glam, no glitter, but you come to this secret little spot for the food. 3/5
-
Price: Dishes come in big, fat platters for two and are around £11 each. Fritters £2. Dumplings £9. Good 4/5
-
Food: Fabulous chicken fried rice, and those crisped on one side pot-sticker dumplings have a wow-factor. 8/10
-
Total: 23/30
La Masa, 26a Renfield Street, Glasgow
La Masa, Glasgow (Image: Colin Mearns)
"Double helping of Birria Tacos then, that beefy, stewy filling, cheeses melded on top of that, and is the taco itself actually fried (no mention of whether in the fat of the stew as it should be)? There are some jangling tanging salsa sensations to clean it all up. We like."
Menu: Tacos, tostadas, blue corn quesadillas and Elote corn; the taco revolution marches on. 3/5
Service: Staff very good, fast, friendly, relaxed and helpful. 5/5
Price: Maybe their secret weapon? Quesadillas £3.50, fish tacos £4, mushroom taco £3.50. Pay more for barbacoa. 5/5
Atmosphere: It’s downtown Glasgow not downtown Mexico City but they pull-off a good, light buzzy vibe. 4/5
Food: Presses the right buttons, varied salsas, reasonably interesting fillings. Only the Birria Tacos stood out. 6/10
Total: 23/30
Rumi, 96 Hope Street, Glasgow
"Deep fried mozzarella; Halloumi fries; Arancini; Spaghetties, Chicken Milanese, Fish ’n’ bloody chips. It would be a rank exaggeration to say a map and compass was needed to find the Turkish dishes but they’re not exactly front and centre."
-
Menu: It’s a Turkish restaurant with Boreks, Sucek Lahmacuns, plus grill skewers and meats plus other Mediterranean dishes. 3/5
-
Service: It has the feel of proper professional staff who don’t overdo the flim-flam but know what they’re about. 4/5
-
Price: Mains can hit £18 and up, starters (hot and cold) hover around, mainly, under the £6 mark. 4/5
-
Atmosphere: On a warm evening was cool, relaxed and comfortable. Shut one eye and maybe it could actually be near the Med. 4/5
-
Food: Not breaking any new ground but they can handle a grill and those starters were all professionally prepared. 7/10
-
Total: 22/30
Piggs Bruntsfield, 117 Bruntsfield Place, Edinburgh
"Let’s be clear here, there’s nothing wrong with the food, it just isn’t that different. Or that interesting."
-
Menu: It’s tapas as we all already know it but Piggs is an Edinburgh hit and serves pinchos, manchego bombas and plenty of other favourites. 3/5
-
Price: They recommend three tapas: ranging from £4.75 for the pan con tomatoe, to £8.75 for Pollo Al Ajillo up to £14 for Pulpo. Egg and chips £7.50. 3/5
-
Service: In my view, the real reason this place is a winner. Excellent smiley, friendly and professional staff. 5/5
-
Atmosphere: Yeah, it’s kind of cool, high tables, bar stools, and that priceless buzz from people who want to be here. 5/5
-
Food: Given the reputation, it's pretty standard tapas fare, competently prepared, the Huevos Rotos Jamon a let down though. 6/10
-
Total: 22/30
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereLast Updated:
Report this comment Cancel