SCOTRAIL has admitted there will be no immediate end to disruption on the railways in the wake of the new timetable chaos as it increased compensation rates for its poor performance.
It comes as unions demanded that the transport secretary Michael Matheson resigns over the handling of the new timetable chaos, while the Scottish Government insist Dutch transport company Abellio, which runs the ScotRail service, would have to be in default of their contract in three consecutive months to remove the franchise from them.
Last month the Scottish Government told the railway operator to submit a plan to address falling performance levels which if unsuccessful would result in one default.
On Monday while the number of service cancellations were cut, a combination of train faults and crew shortages meant that ScotRail had to cut the number of carriages on over 90 services across Scotland - the main reason for passenger overcrowding - and one of the highest levels since the timetable was brought in on December 9.
It has led a host of further complaints to ScotRail, even though the train operator said things were improving while offering offering season ticket holders most affected by cancellations extra compensation by way of free trips on selected routes that have been most impacted.
Showed up at Balloch Station to leaflet commuters about rip off rail fares but guess what, the rush hour train is cancelled. You couldn’t make this up! @ScotRail #scotfail
— Jackie Baillie (@jackiebmsp) January 7, 2019
Most of the disruption that has hit Scots railways since the timetable launch in December 9 was due to ScotRail staff shortages, and the train operator says that is partly because many have been undergoing training on the new trains too late to be ready for the timetable launch.
ScotRail said that was partly caused by the late arrival of the new Hitachi Class 385 and high-speed InterCity trains.
The train operator says the lag in staff training was made worse as a result of RMT industrial action over a pay dispute that lasted several weeks, and was resolved over four weeks ago.
ScotRail say that they have "made progress" since the launch of the timetable having trained 70 drivers and conductors but added: "We know we need to do more."
I’ve been working with @AlexHynes MD at @ScotRail over Christmas to ensure that my constituents aren’t stranded at Dalmeny by trains too full to take them or cancelled as they were throughout Dec. We agreed he’d lay on coaches but I’m here from 6.30am to see everyone gets in. pic.twitter.com/dxGtcaEXFM
— Alex Cole-Hamilton MSP (@agcolehamilton) January 7, 2019
But it has emerged that it still has to train up more than 20 drivers and conductors every day throughout January and February to return service to "levels [passengers] deserve". It says the number of service cancellations had reduced "steadily" over the last few weeks.
The 10-year franchise deal with Abellio for the ScotRail franchise awarded in 2015 allows the contract to be terminated early in 2020, if there was a performance default in three consecutive months.
ScotRail said: "We will continue to cut cancellations to improve your service. We expect week on week improvement through January and February to get your service back to normal levels."
The transport staff union TSSA organised a protest outside Glasgow Central Station supported by Scottish Labour leader Richard Leonard calling for Abellio to be stripped of the ScotRail contract after a rise in rail fares following months of delays and cancellations to trains.
That train is the only option a lot of commuters have from Alloa, Stirling & Larbert to arrive in Edinburgh before 9am and its 2 carriages? I live in Stirling but drive to Falkirk now as there are more trains heading back and forth. So increased train fare and petrol for me!
— Lord Action Wrestling (@lord_action) January 7, 2019
Liz Warren-Corney of the TSSA said Mr Matheson would have to leave his post for the franchise to be stripped from Abellio as she believes he is "ideologically in favour of privatisation" unlike her view of his predecessor Humza Yousaf.
Questioned if Mr Matheson would have to go to achieve change, she said: "Yes. I don't think that would be a bad thing.
"The job of Transport Secretary is to stand up for passengers and when it comes to ScotRail, he has done anything but."
Mr Leonard urged the Scottish Government to use the break clause in the ScotRail franchise to take the railway into public ownership.
The contract could simply be allowed to expire in 2022 rather than be extended to 2025.
"We've seen in the last week fares going up so many of the commuters coming into Glasgow this morning are paying extra for a service which is worse and we think there is huge support for a return of ScotRail into public ownership," he said.
Labour activists have been out across Scotland campaigning for better train services. Those commuting will face the same problems of overcrowding, late or cancelled trains and poor service, yet they will be paying more. We must bring ScotRail back in to public control. pic.twitter.com/0i119uIwdr
— Mary Fee MSP (@MaryFeeMSP) January 7, 2019
"It would mean that every single penny that passengers pay would be reinvested in the railway instead of the current situation where part of that goes back to pay shareholder dividends in Holland."
In November, the Herald revealed that publicly owned Network Rail Scotland is being probed by the transport regulator, the Office of Rail and Road (ORR) as it emerged that it was responsible for two in three of the delays which saw ScotRail forced to settle 35,000 successful claims from passengers in the previous nine months.
Official figures reveal that ScotRail were had to pay out up to 15,683 'delay repay' claims a month over the nine-month period between January and September last year, before the timetable disruption.
The taxpayer will be expected to bare the brunt of those claims estimated by industry figures to come to at least £1m as Network Rail, the nationalised body that manages the infrastructure such as the tracks and the signals, would be expected to compensate ScotRail for problems they were responsible for.
We’re at #Dumfries railway station calling for an end to Abellio’s ScotRail franchise and highlighting @scottishlabour campaign to bring our railways into public ownership to deliver a railway run for passengers not private shareholders #AllChangePlease pic.twitter.com/LziV3e14BV
— Colin Smyth (@ColinSmythMSP) January 7, 2019
ORR data shows that over the year to October 13, 61% of 'delay minutes' affecting ScotRail were blamed on Network Rail, while a further nine per cent were caused by another operator, while one in three delays were laid at the door of ScotRail.
The figures also revealed nearly half of delays to the Scotland to London Caledonian Sleeper were blamed on Network Rail.
Alex Rowley, the former deputy leader of the Scottish Labour Party produced his own video about his concerns.
A Scottish Government spokesman said: “Rail remains a reserved matter under the Scotland Act. Until this changes, we cannot consider the full range of options for running the railways in Scotland in a way which best suits our passengers, freight providers and communities. That is why we are yet again calling on the UK Government, through its rail review, to devolve all rail matters to the Scottish Ministers. Anyone with a genuine interest in improving our railways should get behind this."
The spokesman added: "ScotRail would have to be in default of the contract to enable us to remove the franchise from them. The notion we can simply rip up the contract and put a public sector operator in place is misleading at best.
"Procuring a new contract at this time would come at a significant cost to the public purse and still require a fair and open competition to be run for a new franchisee.
An Abellio spokesman said: "Abellio's focus is on delivering the existing franchise to the highest possible standards, working hard to put in place a railway that better connects passengers, businesses, and communities across Scotland."
A £50 cab fare home on Friday night to Edinburgh from Rosyth after yet another Scotrail cancellation. Scandalously poor service from@@ScotRail
— Freddie Johnson (@freddie801) January 7, 2019
*SCOTRAIL are offering season ticket holders most affected by service cancellations extra compensation by way of free trips on selected routes.
Season ticket holders, accompanied by one extra person on certain routes are being offered travel anywhere on ScotRail services for six specified weekends in March, April and May 2019.
Those delayed by more than 30 minutes, are already entitled to compensation through a Delay Repay Guarantee.
Those delayed by 30 to 59 minutes get 50% of the cost of a single ticket or 25% of a return. It the delay is for an hour to an hour and 59 minutes the compensation is the full cost of a single or half the cost of a return and if it is two hours or more customers get a full refund.
The offer weekends are March 23 and 24, March 30 and 31, April 6 and 7, April 13 and 14, April 27 and 28 and May 11 and 12.
The qualifying routes which covers both directions and all intermediate stations are: Edinburgh - Aberdeen
Edinburgh - Dunblane
Glasgow Queen St – Edinburgh via Cumbernauld
Glasgow Queen St - Aberdeen - Dyce
Glasgow Queen St/Edinburgh - Arbroath
Fife Circle
Glasgow/Edinburgh - Perth/Inverness
Haymarket - North Berwick
Edinburgh - Newcraighall – Tweedbank (Borders)
Aberdeen – Inverness
Montrose - Aberdeen
Inverness - Kyle of Lochalsh
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules here