AS consumers, it seems, we have some pretty confused attitudes to
shellfish. In the UK we consume far more peeled-and-cooked prawns than
the rest of Europe combined. But, as anyone who has tried to buy whole
langoustines or scallops at any of our fishing ports will confirm, these
catches are destined primarily for dining tables in France, Belgium and
Spain.
In Britain, the prawn cocktail offensive has moved far beyond the
Labour Party's assault on the nation's boardrooms. We are all eating
them, apparently, in enormous quantities. But when it comes to more
exotic species, they remain a minority, albeit a growing minority,
taste. Most of us still seem to have problems with any seafood which
retains eyes, bones or an impenetrable shell.
We also, I'm told, persist in associating shellfish with luxury, even
when the numbers suggest otherwise. Despite the growing popularity of
pre-cooked prawns, consumers still rate them a luxury item, a special
treat. Yet, at around #3.49 for a 400g pack, the price is very similar
to a humble piece of chicken filet.
These seem confusing market signals against which to embark on an
ambitious #8.6m investment programme. Especially if you are a private
family business, with no institutional investors, dependent on bank
support to grow. But that is exactly what Alastair Salvesen and his
Dawnfresh Seafoods business did in 1992, when they broke ground on a
former rugby training pitch in Uddingston to build a state-of-the art
processing plant.
The Bothwell Park development has been up and running now for 18
months. Its high risk production hall, where the most scrupulous hygiene
standards are enforced, is capable of producing three tonnes of
peeled-and-cooked cold water prawns every hour.
Next door, in the low risk hall, chilled shellfish deliveries are
received, washed and frozen during the fishing season, stored, and -- as
required by customers throughout the year -- parted from their shells
manually and sent on for further processing. This hall also contains two
coating lines, enabling Dawnfresh to add further value to its raw
material.
''This industry tends to be production-led'' says managing director
John Saunders, ''but we want to be known as a marketing-led, rather than
a production-led operation.'' Dawnfresh has 47 different new products in
various stages of development. Some will inevitably fall by the wayside.
But the aim is introduce one new product every six weeks for the next
eighteen months.
''We will identify the market requirement, the price requirement, and
the customer's margin requirement even before we go into the kitchen to
develop product'' adds Saunders, who joined Dawnfresh in April last
year, after 25 years in other parts of the food processing industry,
latterly with Marshalls, the chicken people.
Alastair Salvesen acquired control of the Dawnfresh business in a 1983
management buy-out, when it was one small part of the Christian Salvesen
empire, known as the South Georgia Company in its old whaling days but,
by then, a force in food storage and distribution, housebuilding, and
assorted other activities like brick making.
As one of the controlling family, he had gone off to Cumbria, to
Whitehaven, where the seafood processing business was then located, to
try and turn round its flagging fortunes. He succeeded. But the
Christian Salvesen board then decided that selling shellfish under its
own brand name, Dawnfresh, wasn't appropriate for a group primarily
interested in storing and distributing food for other people. So
Alastair Salvesen got the opportunity to buy control.
At the time Dawnfresh had an annual turnover of between #2m and #3m.
Three years later, Salvesen reached a crunch decision. ''I came to the
conclusion that we either had to expand considerably or get out of the
business altogether'' he says.
Salvesen surveyed the rest of the marketplace and his eyes alighted on
Starfish, a processor based near Ipswich, which was supplying Marks &
Spencer. A month later he happened to be in Suffolk visiting a Dawnfresh
customer and picked up a rumour Starfish had just been sold. ''We
finished our lunch very quickly, I phoned Starfish and said: I'm coming
over to see you'' he recalls.
The upshot was that Dawnfresh acquired the business and valuable
additional capacity for processing Norwegian prawns. By 1988, Salvesen
had decided he needed to expand Dawnfresh's capacity in its other main
line, scampi. This time his eyes alighted on Mull of Kintyre Seafoods in
Campbeltown.
It was a father and son business and the father, George Mair, was
looking to retire. ''It was another timeous visit'' says Salvesen,
softly. A deal was struck and the son, Michael Mair, like the owner of
Starfish before him, joined the Dawnfresh board. The ex-owner of
Starfish later left to start a mayonnaise business.
The two acquisitions, together with organically-generated growth meant
Dawnfresh was becoming a significantly larger player in its sector. But
the acquisitions also put great strains on the group's senior
management. ''It took five hours to get from Whitehaven to Campbeltown
and a lot more than five hours to get down to Ipswich'' says Salvesen,
recalling regular sorties on the sleeper from Carlisle to London,
sprints up to Suffolk, followed by sleepers back to Cumbria.
In addition, the Ipswich facility, which was leased, was in need of
some serious investment. As the strain of managing three such
geographically dispersed sites grew, Salvesen looked consolidating
everything at Whitehaven. ''But it was the wrong location'' he says now.
''It might have been right when it was a thriving herring port. But most
of the scampi is landed in Scotland now. And Whitehaven was not well
sited on the chilled production line routes.''
The local authority in Whitehaven was not very responsive when
Dawnfresh was looking at the local options. So Salvesen started looking
for a greenfield site elsewhere which made logistical sense -- centrally
sited to receive supplies of scampi from the Scottish ports and imported
cold water prawns, mainly from Iceland, Denmark and Norway, centrally
sited for delivery of the processed product to the major retailers' main
distibution depots.
He looked at Motherwell, attracted by the local food park. But the
sites avaliable there were not quite what he was looking for. Other
Lanarkshire options were also studied and rejected. Then the infant
Lanarkshire Development Agency became involved. Dawnfresh was one of its
very first significant opportunities.
''The LDA found us this site'' says Salvesen. ''We found them very
helpful. They were very reactive and very participative.'' ''This
company has nothing but the highest praise for the LDA'' adds Saunders.
When the Bothwell Park facility opened for business, Ipswich and
Whitehaven closed. A few experienced staff accepted the opportunity to
move north. ''But it was fewer than we would have liked'' adds Salvesen.
''And the numbers have dwindled since.''
That posed a major recruitment and training problem. Bothwell was
built with new, tougher food hygiene regulations firmly at the front of
everyone's mind. Management faced a twin problem. Training staff in the
dextrous manual techniques needed to process shellfish -- the meat is
ejected from the shell by the application of a powerful jet of water,
for example -- had to be a preceded by a campaign to establish, from day
one, a hygiene-conscious culture.
One immediately striking feature of Dawnfresh's Bothwell Park
operation is the high proportion of men on the shelling lines and
elsewhere in the process plant. Women -- witness the electronics sector
-- are widely held to be better and faster at intricate, repetitive
manual tasks. But at Dawnfresh they even had to adapt the changing rooms
as they found a surprisingly high proportion of inexperienced male
recruits took best to the processes.
This may, of course, be a reflection of the huge shake-out in male
manual labour in Lanarkshire following the painful contraction of the
steel and engineering industries. Dawnfresh, which promised 170 jobs
when it opened, is already employing 267, possibly the fastest job build
up in any one company in the area since the Ravenscraig closure.
With Campbetown, where there has been significant investment,
providing front-line processing and supplying export markets with more
exotic shellfish varieties, Dawnfresh Seafoods is now turning over #20m
a year, a near ten-fold increase in a little over ten years. Some of
that growth, of course, has come from acquisitions. But more than half
of it, Salvesen and Saunders reckon, has come from growing their
marketplace.
They face intense price competition, particularly in the supply of
peeled-and-cooked prawns. One major competitor, selling prawns
originating in the Greenland fishery, is a state agency more interested
in supporting the fragile Greenland economy than in making a profit.
''The UK retail trade is one of the most easily penetrable in Europe''
says Saunders, pointing out that the one warehouse, one drop approach of
our supermarket chains is very different from the more complex
distribution channels in Germany or France.
To remain profitable, and able to finance investment on the scale it
has, Dawnfresh has to go on being as efficient and price competitive as
it can be, winning an above-trend share of any market growth. But it is
on more added value products that the really significant advances will,
in future, be won.
''We want to give beef and chicken more competition than they've had
in the past'' says Saunders.
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article