How dogged police work brought a cold, calculating killer to justice.
John Ross reports.
MRS Helen Torbet, 62, met her brutal death at the hands of a man who
showed no remorse. He constructed an elaborate network of deceit to
cover his crime and was brought to justice by a dogged police
investigation.
Having committed the murder, Donald McMillan trussed up his victim's
body and masked her face with bandages and parcel tape. He dumped it in
a shallow grave only yards from his parents' house, covering it with
firewood, coal, and sheets of metal.
He then invented a story of how Mrs Torbet had driven from the
guesthouse with another man, leaving her own car behind.
He was to maintain the deceit over 10 months, repeating the story over
and again to police. He even complained in the press about police
harassment when they returned to question him. His lies were
sufficiently credible to convince his parents and temporarily throw
police off his scent.
Police were later to find his fingerprints on the tape with which Mrs
Torbet had been bound after using liquid nitrogen to separate the glue.
Because of the difficult, rocky ground in the West Highlands and the
presence of his cousin in a nearby caravan, it would have been difficult
to dig the grave on the night of the killing. He had relatives staying
in a caravan near the wood pile and they heard nothing that night.
McMillan went for lunch with them the following day to celebrate their
anniversary, offering no clue that he had just brutally murdered one of
his guests. He even showed little concern for his parents who were
grieving for his father's dying brother-in-law.
They returned from Aberdeen on the Friday but by then McMillan must
have removed the hidden body and dug the 12-inch deep grave. Next to the
woodpile was a big plastic tank which was large enough to hold a corpse.
He hid some of Mrs Torbet's belongings under the floorboards of the
house. Others he inexplicably concealed just 200 yards from the house in
undergrowth near the Inverinate to Kyle of Lochalsh road.
In a strange twist to the tale, police photographed Grianan House from
a helicopter as they carried out extensive sweeps of the area while the
Torbet case was still being treated as a missing person's inquiry.
In the picture, Donald McMillan is seen standing in the garden beside
a pile of logs -- on the very spot where he had buried his innocent
victim.
THE breakthrough in the case came in March when Muriel MacKenzie, from
Glasgow, was on holiday in the area and came across women's belongings
in undergrowth. Not realising their importance, she alerted a forestry
worker who immediately contacted the police.
The items had been concealed beneath willow trees near the Kyle to
Inverinate road by Donald McMillan after he had disposed of Mrs Torbet's
body. Over the winter months they had been covered by snow, but were
exposed in the spring.
The items included Mrs Torbet's handbag, purse, bank cards, her
hillwalking bag -- and a single slipper. Still missing, however, was a
large canvas holdall which was to prove significant later. The discovery
changed the case from a missing-person inquiry into the hunt for a body.
In one of the biggest searches mounted in the Highlands, a helicopter
was hired to take aerial photographs of the entire area, the Royal Navy
was called in to advise on searching Loch Duich, a team of police divers
was brought in and other policemen scoured the mountain terrain.
The investigation team, now convinced Mrs Torbet was dead, decided
first to search the guesthouse itself. At the same time, ground radar --
similar to the equipment used to uncover bodies in the Cromwell Street
investigation in Gloucester -- was brought in.
On entering the guesthouse the team found to their horror it had been
extensively redecorated and recarpeted. Twelve hours into the search,
during which time the team had even opened blocked-up chimneys, they had
still found nothing.
Then, in a downstairs shower room, officers lifted floorboards in a
cupboard and found, well hidden, the missing holdall with Mrs Torbet's
name printed on the handles. Other materials found in a plastic bag
included a slipper which matched the one found by the roadside.
At this point Donald McMillan was detained on suspicion of murder. But
still he kept the police guessing as to how he disposed of Mrs Torbet's
body.
Eventually his devastated parents, unable to take the strain any
longer, pleaded with him to co-operate. The following day he drew a
diagram pinpointing the spot in the back garden where Mrs Torbet was
dumped in a shallow grave.
The Dingwall procurator-fiscal, Mr David Hingston, who was in charge
of the inquiry, said the culmination of the case provided immense
satisfaction on many levels.
For 10 months the Torbet family had not known if she was still alive,
was in pain or in hospital with memory loss.
Mr Hingston said: ''Although it was terrible to find out she was dead,
it is a final act and they were able then to give her a proper burial
which is important psychologically.''
There was also satisfaction, he said, with the way the police
operation was carried out. ''This was not a case where we struck it
lucky -- it was down to dogged, hard work.''
Finally, there was satisfaction in bringing to justice a ''very
dangerous individual'' who had shown no remorse for his crime.
Mr Hingston said: ''It was a cold, calculated killing of an innocent
member of the public and he could have done it again if he hadn't been
caught.''
THE VICTIM
Helen Torbet first stayed in Grianan House at Inverinate about six
years ago, seeing it as the ideal base for her regular hillwalking
expeditions in the hills above Wester Ross. She returned time and again
to the house with its views across Loch Duich.
Mrs Torbet married gynaecology consultant Dr Thomas Torbet on August
12, 1960. They had one son, Alistair. In 1967, they moved to a house in
Busby, where they lived until Mrs Torbet disappeared. Some months after
the police investigation began, Dr Torbet petitioned the court to allow
him to sell the family home and this was permitted. He was obviously
convinced his wife had died and angrily denied any suggestion that his
wife had been having an affair, as hinted at by Donald McMillan.
Dr Torbet, who now lives in Blanefield near Glasgow, was very close to
his wife. During his evidence he recalled every detail about where she
may have bought an item of clothing or jewellery.
Apart from writing for magazines like The Great Outdoors, Mrs Torbet
had been trained as a musician in her younger days. Like her husband,
she was also interested in sailing, and was a recognised yachtmaster
with the Board of Trade.
The couple had another home at Tighnabruaich in the Kyles of Bute
where they kept their boat. Dr Torbet retired from practice in June 1993
from his post at Glasgow's Southern General Hospital.
Mrs Torbet was a staunch campaigner against the introduction of
fluoride into public water supplies. She also had her eccentricities --
taking a jar of pulses, cereals and nuts in a jar as well as her own
water while on an expedition.
She kept a meticulous diary of all the climbs she made and what she
saw on her expeditions, from birds to trees and plants. She even
corrected Ordnance Survey maps.
THE KILLER
DONALD McMillan's motive for murder was sexual. The 33-year-old former
soldier, who claimed he wore women's underwear, had a fascination for
older women which proved fatal for Mrs Torbet.
Police found pornographic magazines in the caravan where he stayed
alone next to the guesthouse run by his mother. The naked models were
rated with stars. Younger women were marked at around 10 and 20 while
the few pictures of women over 40 were awarded marks of up to 500.
McMillan found it difficult to speak to women of his own age but wrote
letters to numerous women in the area. Even while awaiting trial he
continued his almost obsessive correspondence with local girls. One
described it as ''really frightening''. The letters were not aggressive
or even sexy. They were full of gushing romantic phrases.
One letter was given to Mrs Torbet with whom he had struck up a
totally innocent relationship during her regular trips to Inverinate and
who was old enough to be his mother.The last entry in Mrs Torbet's
diary, written on the night she died, read: ''Strange letter awaited me
from Donald McMillan. Embarrassing to cope with.'' Police have never
discovered the letter.
Donald McMillan was born in Stranraer and left school in Ayrshire
without qualifications. After working as a dairy farm assistant and
trainee manager with the Co-op, he joined the Army as a clerk in 1979.
He served first with the Royal Armoured Corps in the Royal Scots Dragoon
Guards and saw service in Germany and Northern Ireland.
His career in the service was undistinguished and he left after
serving six months in Army detention after going absent without leave.
He later joined his parents in Inverinate where his mother, Zena, began
ran a bed-and-breakfast guesthouse with husband Donald. Donald junior
helped around the house and garden.
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article