THE Maastricht Summit produced a historic treaty this morning, with
the Prime Minister's signature stamped firmly on it. ''It is game, set
and match for Britain,'' he said.
The EC leaders agreed the treaty on economic, monetary, and political
union, after Mr Major convinced them to clear out all the social
reforms. It took 14-hours of solid negotiation.
Mr Major was ''absolutely delighted. It's what we've always wanted''.
''The whole social chapter has been dropped,'' a British official
said, confirming that the other 11 EC countries would strike a separate
deal on more common social legislation outside the EC framework.
The outcome was little short of a master stroke for Mr Major -- at
least in the short term. For months in the run-up to the summit, the
Prime Minister flew to EC capitals to negotiate with his colleagues and
he warned all of them that social policy was the one issue on which he
would not budge.
EC Commission President Jacques Delores claimed that Britain was in
the slow lane of Europe. But Mr Major countered: ''There is a one speed
Europe and Britain is in the lead.''
Mr Delores asserted that Britain had been playing by different rules
in the negotiations. ''I prefer the rules of football and perhaps your
compatriot prefers the rules of rugby -- therefore it is difficult to
find the criteria to assess the performance of your Prime Minister.'' Mr
Major countered again in television interviews: ''It's game set and
match to Britain.''
The EC President Ruud Lubbers was asked to state the difference
between Mrs Thatcher and her successor Mr Major. He said: ''The United
Kingdom is still the same -- but the Foreign Secretary, Mr Hurd doesn't
have a handbag.''
Mr Major said at his news conference: ''We have surrendered nothing
and lost nothing.'' The Prime Minister was clearly delighted with what
he described as ''a good day for Britain and a good day for Europe. I
think it is a success for Britain and the whole Community.''
Mr Major was speaking shortly after winning a series of hard-fought
concessions over closer political and monetary union in marathon talks
with the other EC leaders.
The deal struck at the Maastricht summit will give the Community a
single currency by 1999 at the latest and lead to closer links between
the member states.
The breakthrough came after the other leaders agreed to Mr Major's
demand to remove from a political union treaty plans handing social
policy powers to Brussels.
Social policy was the biggest stumbling block throughout the
negotiations, and it was only swept aside after a day of what British
officials called ''hard pounding'' by Mr Major.
He stood alone and insisted the Government could not accept EC
interference in social legislation, with majority voting at Community
level on sensitive issues like working hours, worker consultation and
equal treatment between men and women in the labour market.
A furious France immediately tabled a protocol -- effectively an
opt-out for the 11 other nations -- declaring that they will consider
how to go ahead on their own. At midnight only France had signed it and
the other countries were concerned that costly provisions concerning
employment, wages, working conditions, maternity leave, sick leave, and
a whole host of other items may put them at a commercial disadvantage
with Britain.
A British Government source said: ''If this puts us at a competitive
advantage, we will have to live with that.''
The Prime Minister appears to have brought off a negotiating triumph
as the social dimension of the political treaty was one that he could
not sign and keep the Tory Party together. It should go a long way to
placating Mrs Thatcher, Mr Norman Tebbit, and other Tory Euro-sceptics
when the Prime Minister faces the Commons with the result.
Mr Major will claim that if other countries of the 11 introduce social
reforms that are useful, Britain will join in. If they go ahead with the
kind of reforms that Mr Major has claimed would cost British industry
#3500m and impair competitiveness with Japan and the United States,
Britain will stay out.
''It's the best of all possible worlds,'' said one of the Major team.
The decision appears to rule out any intervention by the European
Commission, the European parliament, or the Court of Justice because
Britain cannot be forced to comply with whatever France and others might
do. The other countries would be acting outside treaty requirements.
Chancellor Kohl of Germany is believed to have come down on the side
of Mr Major against President Mitterrand, whose one page protocol
declares that France will go ahead with the social charter that they
signed up to. But the protocol specifically states: ''These acts are not
applicable to the UK.''
The result astonished the other nations who believed that at the
eleventh hour Mr Major would be forced to bend to the majority desire of
the 12.
On a single currency, Britain won another concession, being given the
right to opt out of monetary union whenever it is introduced.
The Prime Minister was jubilant as he addressed a news conference
after his Maastricht triumph.
He said: ''We have had two-and-a-half days of intense, detailed and
occassionally tough negotiations.
''I am very happy at the outcome. I think it is a success both for
Britain and for the whole of the Community.''
Mr Major could scarcely disguise his delight as he ran through the
events at the summit. What he has achieved will almost certainly bode
well for him and the Conservative party when he chooses to call the next
General Election.
Some observers believe that he will now opt for going to the country
sooner rather than later while this triumph remains fresh in the minds
of Britain's voters.
Even the Tory Euro-sceptics who have been plaguing him with their
doubts over the past three or four months, led by Mrs Thatcher, will
surely find the outcome to their liking.
Mr Major told the news conference: ''Our main objective in the
economic and monetary union treaty was to secure a legal and water-tight
provision so that the United Kingdom can decide whether it wants to join
a single currency or not, and if it does when it should join.
''We have achieved that in a legally binding protocol which forms an
integral part of the treaty.
''We have secured strict convergence conditions (similarities in
inflation and interest rates and budget deficits) before any of the
countries can move to stage three.
''We have achieved absolute control over monetary policy in stage
two.''
Mr Major made clear that Britain accepted there was a social dimension
within the Community.
''What we could not accept was a further extension of Community
competence to do with employer and employee relations.''
He stressed that he had said before coming to Maastricht that he could
not accept the text of a treaty that would allow the Community to
''drive a coach and horses through what we have achieved in trade union
legislation over the last decade''.
And he repeated that the social chapter had been dropped entirely from
the treaty.
The Prime Minister spoke of the need to enlarge the Community to
include Eastern European countries and former EFTA states.
He said enlargement would be something that Britain could carry
forward during its presidency in the second half of next year.
''The greatest challenge to the Community is not our internal
developments but how the Community as a whole matches up to the dramatic
events taking place all around us.''
In the final, remarkable sessions of this summit it seems that the
Prime Minister had been able to turn the tables on his enemies. He has
got a legally binding opt-out from a single currency and a central bank
without any terminal date on the validity of the opt-out. At the same
time he negotiated the clever use of language which allows the other 11
to opt-out of the British position on the social charter without any
treaty penalty to Britain.
Federalism has been removed from the treaty text, and the individual
sovereignty of the 12 nations has been beefed up. There will be no EC
intervention in industry without unanimous agreement, and the continuing
primacy of Nato with its American shield is established.
ON defence, Mr Major has agreed to the principle of a common EC
defence policy, centred on the Western European Union but not
undermining the traditional role of Nato and the transatlantic defence
link.
On immigration, the Government has given way on majority voting for
short-term visas, and there is also majority voting on more
environmental matters.
On European Parliament powers, Mr Major made concessions but only on
minor matters. He has ensured that there is Westminster Parliament
scrutiny of the Brussels Commission, particularly over finance.
On industrial policy, unanimous voting has been retained.
On ''federal,'' the word was dropped and Britain won the acceptable
alternative of ''ever closer union.''
On cash transfers from northern EC states to poorer southern members,
there is a special protocol for Spain.
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article