Allan McGraw, in charge of young talent at Morton, has paid the price
for a brave but reckless playing career. And he is determined
no-one else should suffer, finds Ian Paul.
IF THE football gods had played fair, they would have seen to it that
Morton, the team managed by Allan McGraw, were the winners of the B&Q
Cup at Hampden last Sunday. But McGraw has long since learned that it
can be a very long wait if you expect favours from the great dug-out in
the sky.
The defeat by Hamilton left him depressed, but the vicissitudes of the
old ball game do not dampen the McGraw psyche for any length of time. He
has good cause to consider the odd defeat as relatively minor in the
great panoply of the game.
McGraw is a limping, live example of the extraordinary gamble some
footballers can take with their limbs. He was one of the most prolific
scoring centre forwards of his or any other era but paid a price which
is far too great.
It is a wincing irony that his best total of 58 goals for a season, a
record for any senior striker in Britain, came in 1963-64, the same
season in which he suffered the knee injury which in due course was to
leave him walking with sticks.
He has replacement joints in both knees, suffers constant pain and
prays that science will yet come to his rescue. It is a scenario which
he hopes will serve as a warning for all young professional players,
for, to a certain extent, he was a conspirator in the strategy that has
left him in this unhappy situation.
''I had my cartilage removed earlier but it was in that season I took
a knee knock. Morton were going so well -- 23 winning games in
succession -- that I took cortisone injections every second week and
just kept playing.'' If it seems astounding now to hear that this went
on for a year, McGraw recalls that it didn't raise much of a fuss then.
''The older players told me I was daft, right enough, but when you're
young you just want to play and enjoy it while it is going well.
''The only criticism I have is that no doctor ever told me the damage
it could do. Maybe I would just have played on anyway but it was never
pointed out to me.'' His routine will sound mind-boggling to many a
current player, with highly skilled physios and medical experts around
the place. He didn't train during the week, to allow the swelling on the
knee to come down. After the rest ''cure'', he would then play on the
Saturday and restart the cycle.
''It was very painful but, ach, once you got on the park it was OK.''
Five years later, now with Hibs, still playing and still suffering, he
was hurt playing in a League Cup semi-final against Dundee. His last
game, like so much of the McGraw story, included a painful irony. He was
injured and taken off but brought back on when another player was forced
to leave the field. He adds ruefully: ''I scored a goal . . . in injury
time.'' He knows now that he should have been rested from playing for at
least three months following the original injury. ''Don't get me wrong,
I don't knock cortisone. It is a great drug if used properly but I
mis-used it.'' The consequence was a succession of operations to his
knees . . . ''the strain put on the other knee ended up doing it damage
too'' . . . with one artificial joint being inserted eight years ago and
the other four years later.
''When I was 33 I was told by the surgeon that I had the knees of a
man of 70. Now I hope that there will be a new discovery that will
help.'' All of which should not be presumed to make this man a
self-pitying depressive. The opposite is the case. His love of the sport
transcends even his own devastating experience. The inability to
demonstrate in a track suit the coaching knowledge he possesses is a
drawback but it has not stopped him discovering and nurturing some
tremendous young talent at Greenock, where he has spent most of his
football life. His scoring ability as a player with the club is never
going to be equalled. In his seven playing years at Cappielow, he scored
at least 30 goals a season.
After finishing with Hibs, he spent a couple of seasons coaching
junior clubs before becoming reserve coach at Greenock. A succession of
managers came and went before he was given the reins in 1985, since when
he has ridden the roller-coaster that is the inevitable lot of managers
in the lower regions of the league.
But his talent for finding players, encouraging them and sending them
on to higher grades is well proven. He reckons he has brought in more
than a million pounds in his dealings with bigger clubs.
Why this love affair with Morton? ''I suppose it is because it is a
family club, a welcoming club. When you see the number of players who
left here that come back to see us, you realise it has a special
attraction. It is just a great wee club.'' He won a second division
championship with Morton as a player, lited the same title as a manager
and played in the League Cup final when Morton lost to Rangers. Victory
in last week's final would have given him and the club another milestone
but, as you might expect, he takes it philosophically.
That is not to say the McGraw ambitions have been dimmed. He points
out with pride that Morton owe nothing. ''We will never get into debt
again. We vowed to get out of the situation where this club was owned by
the banks. And we have.'' If he stops short of visualising the European
Cup at Cappielow, McGraw refuses to curtail thrilling imaginings like
premier divsion status. ''I believe this club can get there but more
important, because we have been there before, is to build a team which
can stay there. Our role model has to be Dundee United and Jim McLean.
He showed us all that it can be done.''
Yet he scotches the notion that he will remain an integral part of the
Greenock scenario. ''People say I am in with the bricks but I know
things can change easily and I could get the sack. Nobody is
indispensable but I will never resign. They will have to throw me out.''
McGraw's earthy, self-deprecating style, typical of his generation of
football folk, disguises a pride which is disturbed only by the nuisance
of his physical problems. His knee joints can lock at any time without
warning and the consequent collapse can come at the most inappropriate
of moments. But the pride swells when he talks of his family, wife Jean,
and sons Allan and Mark. Perhaps it should come as no surprise to
discover that the junior Allan's football career has been shattered by
injury and that Mark, now with Hibernian, is off injured at the moment.
The fact that Mark never saw his dad without sticks remains an inner
pain but, more than anything else, the unintentional but nonetheless
self-inflicted disability angers him because of the extra burden it has
put on Jean.
''That is what is the worst part. She has to do the decorating in the
house, the gardening, the lot. She has been behind me 100 per cent but
it has been tough.'' McGraw did not receive any insurance benefits from
his enforced retiral from the game and calls the #4000 compensation
handed out to one of his own players, Jimmy Simpson, a few years ago ''a
disgrace''.
Understandably, he is specially careful about fielding players who are
recovering from injury and genuinely wants to make sure that his brutal
experience is used as a warning for footballers everywhere.
Take him away from the hustle and bustle of the dug-out on a Saturday
and he will confess: ''It is the little things you miss. I would love to
be able to take my wee niece out for walks, for example, but I can't.
But it is all done with now. There's no point complaining.''
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article