GIVEN the very serious implications of the statements in Mr Martyn Imrie's letter (June 1), I felt the need to clarify the position of HMI in relation to the Nicolson Institute, Stornoway.

The HMI report on the care and welfare of pupils in the Nicolson Institute was published in June 1997. It made a number of recommendations for action. Responsibility for implementing the HMI recommendations lies with the Western Isles Council, the education authority, and the school.

HMI do not have executive membership of the council group which has been established to oversee implementation of these recommendations. A follow-up report detailing progress will be published by HMI in August 1998. Throughout, HMI have taken an independent view and reported accordingly.

Graham H C Donaldson,

HM Depute Senior Chief Inspector

of Schools,

St Andrew's House, Edinburgh.

June 3.