AN operating theatre. The camera catches the handsome young surgeon's
piercing blue eyes from above his mask. It is a look of sheer
concentration. A nurse mops his sweating brow as he delivers his lines.
''Forceps,'' he says; ''clamp.'' In the background there is the steady
beep of a heart monitor. Everyone looks worried sick, and all they're
doing is removing a wean's tonsils.
Ah, don't you just love medical dramas. Well, someone must. Never
before in the history of television have there been so many of them on
our screens. The BBC, ITV and Channel Four seem to be permanently
engaged in a game of doctors and nurses.
Count them. Already this year we've had Casualty, Dangerfield, and Dr
Finlay. Currently we've got ER, Chicago Hope, and Peak Practice. Add to
this a list which has included Dr Kildare, Ben Casey, St Elsewhere,
Emergency Ward Ten, General Hospital, and A Country Practice, and you
soon realise that sickness, particularly when it's life-threatening, is
a healthy crowd puller for television.
Why? Is it a case of there but for the grace of God (and good health)
goes the viewer? Or is it perhaps because we get a vicarious pleasure
from seeing gallons of blood spilled on the operating table as patients
are cut open with the surgeon's scalpel? Maybe it's a bit like that
ghoulish compulsion we have about real accidents: how a crowd is always
drawn to the scene of a road crash.
Whatever the reason, it means a guaranteed audience rating. You want a
hit show? Then make it medical. Touch and go; life and death. There you
are of a Saturday evening, dipping into your tacco chips, and on the
screen before you is a scene which bears a striking resemblance to the
salsa sauce on the coffee table -- a shot of an emergency tracheotomy at
Holby General. And why is it that every time someone has a heart attack
on the telly, you suddenly feel a sharp pain in your arm, a mysterious
tightness in your chest? Or is that just me?
Of the current crop of medi-dramas, ER with its frantic pace, beats
all the rest into a cocked hat. Ambulances literally crash through the
double doors of the casualty department; hip doctors leap on top of
patients and thump their hearts back to life; surgeons cut to the sound
of James Brown blasting through a set of speakers in the operating
theatre -- and no scene is more than a minute long.
There are a number of standard character requirements for any
successful medical drama, of course. A hospital helps, for a start. Then
you need a heart-throb -- usually a conscientious, young male doctor
(divorced because his wife couldn't handle the long hours) who is
constantly under pressure and looks as if he's in danger of cracking up.
Then you need the flawed genius brain surgeon -- over-confident and
self-important; a man who does not respect authority, a man who takes
risks.
Naturally there also has to be a beautiful woman. She can either be a
doctor or a nurse -- maybe a receptionist at a pinch -- and she has to
have had an affair (now finished) with one or both of the aforementioned
doctors.
Last, you need the voice of reason -- usually in the shape of a
balding, more mature doctor who's been there, seen it, done it, and
lived to tell the tale. The only requirement left is a sad collection of
patients, suffering from terminal cancer, extraordinarily rare diseases,
and serious injuries which need dramatic emergency treatment.
Then along comes the second series of Cardiac Arrest (BBC1, Wednesday)
and breaks the mould; kind of. The NHS hospital from Hell. Virginia
Bottomley's anti-Christ. If ER was fast, then this is positively racing.
In the first of eight half-hour shows there are more dead bodies than
you could shake a stethoscope at.
Directors Jim Gillespie and Sam Miller have built this one for speed.
Writer John McUre, a former junior doctor in an NHS hospital, tells it
like it is. It's riddled with humour that's darker than two in the
morning. You don't laugh at the jokes, you shudder. A young doc tries to
revive a patient suffering from horrendous chest injuries after a car
crash. The intern gives him cardiac massage but, as he thumps his chest,
his hands smash through the rib cage. ''Oops,'' says the doc.
Cardiac Arrest, made by Tony Garnett's World Productions for BBC
Scotland, was shot in an unused section of Stobhill Hospital, Glasgow.
Most of the cast from the first series return -- with the classy
addition of Australian Peter O'Brien (the pilot in Flying Doctors) as a
roller-skating surgical registrar aka ''Scissors''.
McUre says: ''The second series has been written to be faster. It's
better television; and in medicine lots of things are happening at once,
and people who can keep pace get better results.
''I was still working as a doctor when I wrote the first series, and
the experience I had then suggested there were other things that needed
to be said about the NHS. I became more politically involved with the
NHS through my involvement with the BMA and the Junior Doctors'
Committee.
''In the past year there have been a lot of stories in the press
reflecting the relationships between doctors, nurses, and managers.
Managers are blaming the medical staff and hospital staff are blaming
managers.''
McUre (his name is a pseudonym) hated his job as a doctor and he hopes
that the programme gets over the message that there's a great deal of
resentment and anger about the working conditions of junior hospital
doctors.
''That's not something I can write about in a detached way. I was
there -- and those things happened to me. Not necessarily in the form
they're portrayed on television, but experiences like them happened all
the time. It's a very genuine personal anger and I've tried to put that
into the series,'' he says.
SEALED with a controversial kiss, Roger Michell's Screen Two film
adaptation of Jane Austen's Persuasion (BBC2, Sunday) will raise a few
eyebrows among the literary purists. For this classic love story,
starring Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds, the respected director has
dispensed with much of the costume gloss we have come to expect from
television period drama. Instead he relies on a more realistic approach
with crumpled clothes and a conspicuous absence of fancy wigs.
Austen's tale concerns the relationship between the heroine, Anne
Elliot, and her ex-fiance, dashing naval captain Frederick Wentworth.
When the couple meet again seven years after their break-up, old
emotions come back to haunt them and, eventually, alter the course of
their lives.
Ultimately, the film strays from the author's original story line by
ending with a kiss between the two main characters. The passionate
embrace was insisted on by the BBC's co-producer, a US TV company, to
suit American audiences. Originally, Michell made two endings for the
film, one for the British and the other for the Americans. But when he
compared them he decided that the kiss was necessary, so he kept it in
for both sides of the Atlantic.
IT'S a choice between vicars and tarts on Sunday night as The Choir
(BBC1) and Band of Gold (Scottish) reach their respective conclusions.
Curiously, bearing in mind the very different subject matter, it could
be a difficult choice. Joanna Trollope's story of Middle England
cassock-and-surplice intrigue has improved over the course of its
four-week run, thanks to some fine casting and well-paced direction.
But it's Kay Mellor's gritty, compelling, North of England drama about
prostitutes which wins on points. In the final episode we find out the
identity of Gina's killer -- who could be one of half-a-dozen male
characters, each one seedier than the one before. Thanks to the success
of the series -- 14 million viewers have tuned in every week -- Granada
Television has now embarked upon a sequel.
Trollope, meanwhile, would appear to be the flavour of the month on
television. A Village Affair (Scottish, Monday), a two-hour adaptation
of another of her novels, stars Sophie Ward, Kerry Fox, and Nathaniel
Parker. It is, as its name rather suggests, the story of a passionate
and illicit love affair which explodes one summer in an apparently
idyllic English village.
JIMMY Perry and David Croft have provided television with some of the
most durable sitcoms of the past 25 years, including It Ain't Half Hot
Mum, Dad's Army, and Hi-de-Hi! Now Omnibus (BBC1, Tuesday) celebrates
their writing partnership. The affectionate profile traces their career
from its origins in the early sixties.
Croft, then a respected director of classic comedy shows, was working
on Hugh And I and cast Perry in a minor role. During conversation, Perry
suggested the idea for a sitcom based on his experiences in the Home
Guard -- and Dad's Army was born. Later the pair, who had both been
stationed in India during their National Service, started working on It
Ain't Half Hot, Mum.
They discuss their work, which they describe as ''the comedy of
failure'', and the origins of some of their key characters. The
programme also includes contributions from, among others, Bob Monkhouse,
Clive Dunn and Su Pollard.
THIS week sees the welcome return of the
perfectly-rehearsed-but-entirely-spontaneous quiz show, Have I Got News
For You (BBC2, Friday). Julian Clary and Labour MP Diane Abbott join the
usual suspects: Merton, Hislop, and Deayton, in the first of the new
series. Safe to assume that Nick Leeson, the latest round of ministerial
resignations, and Martin Amis's very expensive teeth will feature in the
ensuing weeks.
In a bid to keep the show fresh, some new rounds have been introduced.
They include one on the daft sentences handed out by even dafter judges,
another about celebrity quangos, and a third in which each team is
provided with the plans to some of Britain's top jails and invited to
plot an escape.
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article