The home sick boy who turned into the hard man of football.
THE soiled linen of Danielle and Graeme Souness's stormy marriage has
been well and truly washed and hung out on banner headlines these past
days with little dignity left on either side. You wonder if people ever
stop to consider the children.
On the matrimonial level, psychiatrists have their own standard
judgment of what happens. Even when contemplating marriage, they will
tell you, men have an inborn resistance to women, a personal animosity
at an unconscious level, which they generally manage to shed before
proceeding to the much likelier success of the second-time-round.
More interesting than the Souness marriage, however, the man himself
becomes the fascinating study of the working-class Scottish lad, brought
up in an Edinburgh prefab, blessed with an exquisite footballing talent,
who comes face to face with high success -- then seems to blow it.
Many in Scotland are still working out why in 1991, at the point of
triumph with a vista of much more to come, Graeme Souness suddenly
walked away from his friend David Murray, chairman of Rangers, and all
they were building together in the quest for European success.
One moment he was declaring he would not contemplate leaving his
manager's job at Ibrox for the Liverpool vacancy created by the
departure of his friend, Kenny Dalglish; but soon he was off to that
same job.
Was he lured back to the scene of his greatest playing triumphs by a
secret desire to win the European Cup again, this time as manager?
Was it a furious reaction to the punishment meted out by the ruling
body of Scottish football, with which he was constantly at loggerheads?
Or a gesture to the Scottish press, which criticised him at its peril
but let him away too often with the sycophantic soft-pedal?
A persecution complex? An itchy finger on the button of self-destruct?
The puzzle may never be solved.
What we do know is that the seeds of conflict were with him from early
days.
Brought up in the Saughton Mains district of Edinburgh, he went to the
same school as the great Dave Mackay, the Spurs and Scotland star who
spotted him. He followed Mackay's golden route to White Hart Lane.
But he walked out with mutterings of homesickness.
Then came a second chance, this time at Middlesbrough, where there
were rows and he was asked to leave.
Thus came the greatest playing opportunity of all, the offer to join
high-flying Liverpool, the greatest team in England. And there he
emerged as the natural successor to the Jim Baxters and Paddy Crerands.
Enter Danielle, daughter of a Merseyside multi-millionaire
businessman, Austin Wilson, who had retired to Majorca and settled on
her a trust of #750,000.
Souness was soon on his way to Italy, orchestrating a Sampdoria team
owned by a man called Mantovani.
Meanwhile, back in Scotland, the Rangers' domination, which had long
been suffering from the power of Jock Stein's Celtic and the
impertinence of Alex Ferguson's Aberdeen, needed restoring.
At 33, Graeme Souness was dramatically produced as the player-manager
of a club still owned by the John Lawrence family.
But in his very first match, back on the home territory of Easter
Road, Edinburgh, he was ordered off for an incident which sparked off
rammy. Souness confessed he looked up at the grandstand, spotted his
father and felt ashamed. Rangers were fined #5000 and he was banned for
three games.
However, the new man did go on to claim the premier division
championship, Rangers' first for nine years.
At the start of his second season he was ordered off again, against
Celtic at Parkhead, charged with verbally abusing referee David Syme,
who later described him as ''the most arrogant, spoiled man I have ever
come across in football''. Syme added: ''As a player, he was one of the
dirtiest tacklers I have ever seen.''
All this of a man who was also one of the silkiest performers to pull
on a Scottish jersey.
By November 1988 there were sensational happenings of a better tone at
Ibrox. Wealthy industrialist David Murray, a friend of Souness, bought
over Rangers at the unthinkable bargain price of #6m, giving the manager
the chance to take a 10% stake.
Shrewdly, Murray was giving him good reason to stay around. The
Souness family set up home, luxuriously, in Edinburgh but were soon
hitting the headlines with the announcement that the marriage was on the
rocks. Danielle had gone back to Majorca with the children.
Through continuing conflict with the SFA, he changed the Rangers'
habit of a century by signing the most controversial of Roman Catholics,
Maurice Johnston, who had nearly gone to Celtic. That inevitably brought
flak from some Ibrox supporters but applause from the rest of Scotland.
Fined #5000 for breaching a touchline ban, Souness told an
interviewer: ''There's a lot I don't like about myself but there are
some things which are just you and can't be changed, no matter how you
try.''
There were things which other people didn't like either. The Herald's
James Traynor turned up at a Souness press conference to be told that
his recent critical article was an unmentionable substance and that he
was just jealous that Rangers players earned ten times what he earned.
Traynor was dismissed as ''a little socialist'' and banned, just as had
happened to the Express man and Scottish Television.
Were the pressures too much? Whatever the cause, he wasn't learning,
plunging into further trouble with the SFA for saying there were too
many hammer-throwers in Scottish football.
But he was not alone in feeling pressure. Kenny Dalglish was quitting
Liverpool and rumour was rife that Souness would replace him. There were
denials and vows of loyalty to Rangers. But off he went.
David Murray told him quietly he was making the biggest mistake of his
life. The 10% share of Rangers was now worth #1m. And from the court
case just finished, he appears to have indicated that his fortune has
now risen to #8m. Not bad for a wee lad from Saughton Mains.
But the pressures were building. After less than a year at Liverpool
he felt unwell and the diagnosis was shattering: an immediate heart
by-pass -- or you will die.
Was there no end to Souness's misfortunes? With the football club
heading for its worst season in 30 years, he found himself in trouble
with English referees -- and faced the grief that his loving father, who
had had the same heart operation as himself, had died of a heart attack.
Events overtook him and he finally quit the Liverpool job last
January. He now manages Galatasaray of Turkey.
More recently still came the libel suit against the People newspaper,
after Danielle's accusations brought the headlines of ''dirty rat''.
As a leading psychiatrist confirmed to me last night, there is a
psychological condition where people can go along quite smoothly in
their daily lives, being charming, pleasant and competent. Suddenly they
will do something which seems quite crazy. It is something which is easy
to condemn, if less easy to understand and grant sympathy.
Yet sympathy and understanding may well be what it needs -- except,
of course, when you collect #750,000.
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article