AVERY civilised war is non-raging between Scottish Television and BBC
Scotland. And, oh what a stylish war! . . . as might be expected when
the territory being fought over is the coverage of the arts, a very big
field in Scotland 1990.
On the high ground, and hanging on determinedly against the big guns
of BBC London money, are STV with their weekly NB series. They have a
veritable ball-of-fire commander in producer Donny O'Rourke and are
being kept under constant scrutiny by diminutive BBC producer May Miller
and her laid-back supremo John Archer. There is a suggestion at
Cowcaddens that the scrutiny has been a little too close and all that
has been captured so far have been O'Rourke's ideas about the concept
for an arts programme, first with Excess and now with Saturday Night
Clyde.
In the BBC camp they have been keeping their heads down as though
nothing else was happening. A couple of heat-seeking missiles that could
cause hurt have been sent off in the direction of Queen Margaret Drive.
One is the suggestion that Saturday Night Clyde (SNC) is like NB on
tranquillisers. Potentially more damaging is a report from the front
that NB is picking up higher ratings in Central Scotland than is SNC
which is being shown all over Britain on the BBC2 network. It was left
to BBC's Naked Radio to flush the matter into the open by lampooning the
presenters of NB. ''Now we know we have arrived,'' says O'Rourke.
As a neutral observer, I can see considerable qualities in the
programmes of the two sides, but have to admit that they are qualities
of great similarity. And the fact remains that Scottish were first in
the field.
This is the situation so far: O'Rourke, with full encouragement from
his supremo, Alistair Moffat, started from scratch, recruited a small,
dedicated army -- more like a platoon, really -- to go into what was
unknown territory. There had not been a regular all-embracing arts show
at Scottish for years. It was a high risk area, and, possibly in case
the team was not going to survive, they were kept at bay, billeted in
Nissen huts (or Portakabins) in the STV car park.
O'Rourke had very clear ideas about his plan of strategy. The show had
to be entertaining, fast-moving, and it was essential that the many
areas of the arts being dealt with should be seen in a serious light.
He wanted a freshness of approach, something that would be helped if
the presenters were not regular TV faces. In this he got off to a flying
start by signing up Janice Forsyth. He had been to university with her
and, as his television career developed, he determined that if the
opportunity arose, she would make a good presenter. She was bright,
could turn a phrase, and had personality. Yet until NB her only
association with TV had been as a researcher. Most of her career had
been doing PR for things like the Edinburgh Festival Fringe. O'Rourke
then placed adverts for the other two presenters in List magazine and on
the notice boards of drama colleges. There were more than 800 responses.
These were whittled down to eight who were camera tested and from these
came Allan Campbell and Bryan Burnett.
A fairly fervent nationalist, brought up in a socialist household,
O'Rourke had also been determined that NB would have an all-Scottish
team.
Having recruited a youngish, trendy trio of presenters, none of whom
had ever been on television before, he was lucky in getting director
Alistair Scott, a graduate of the National Film and Television School,
Beaconsfield, whom he considers one of the best in the country. Scott
played a big part in creating the special identity of the programme, the
subliminal buzz style and backing rap sound. Chris Buckland did such
clever things as video editor that he has now been promoted to second
director. Everyone struck an instant rapport, says O'Rourke. A team was
born. Presenter Campbell co-wrote the rap music that helped establish an
identity.
Young though the presenters might be, they were targeting at the full
age range. ''So often, if you don't look like them, sound like them,
come from the same part of England as some of the TV presenters today,
they have no time for you,'' says O'Rourke.
He got three contrasting people to do what he describes as ''little
NBs'' setting the mood before the titles -- Pat Kane of pop group Hue
and Cry (now in the other camp with SNC), John Mauceri of Scottish
Opera, and Una McLean, representing the rich tradition of Scottish
vaudeville. What does NB stand for? someone was bound to ask. There are
several explanations -- like Nae Bother, No bullshit, North British. It
has been inherited from an earlier show that was never made, mainly for
financial reasons. It would have been called NB?, questioning the
description promulgated by Walter Scott that Scotland was just north
Britain -- ''Which is far from the case,'' says the nationalistic
O'Rourke.
Now we switch to Queen Margaret Drive where the arts unit thrives
under John Archer who has the ear and the money of Alan Yentob,
Controller BBC2. Whisper it not, Archer, head of music and arts,
Scotland, is an Englishman, but a very pleasant, charismatic member of
the species. NB was alive and successful when they launched Excess,
which, from behind the Cowcaddens binoculars was also seen as a show
with a two-letter title -- Excess: XS. Or maybe there was an implied
warning shot: Nothing succeeds like Excess.
New faces were in at the BBC, too. Clare English, the young presenter,
had never been seen before on television. Then there was the rap music,
the subliminal repetitiveness, a show looking and sounding almost
identical to NB. The format has been carried over to the current
Saturday Night Clyde. Co-presenters on Clyde are Kane and the ubiquitous
Stuart Cosgrove. There are those at Scottish who say that if they had
not taken the risk with new presenters, Excess would have had a familiar
face instead of Clare English.
One difference between the two programmes is that SNC might stay with
a subject longer than NB that packs 15 items into 24 and a half minutes
(a commercial half hour). ''Because of the time span, if John Lennon and
Elvis came back from the dead and got together as a duo, they'd get one
minute and 25 seconds on NB,'' says O'Rourke.
Initial reports from the front indicate that SNC which lists a lot
more names when the screen credits roll, is picking up something like
300,000 viewers nationwide whereas NB is ahead with about 400,000, its
audience centred on Glasgow and Edinburgh. When you get the cumulative
figures from a Saturday repeat and Grampian and Border also transmitting
it, the figure is nearly a million.
Apart from having a lot of energy, O'Rourke, still under 30, is a man
with a wide variety of interests, making him the kind of person capable
of coping with being an arts producer. He went to St Mirin's Academy,
Paisley (John Byrne is another ex-pupil) then Glasgow University for
English and history. He went to London where he was chairman of the
British Youth Council, a coalition of every youth organisation in
Britain, from the Young Communists League to the Girl Guides. This is an
agitation group set up after the war to promote better relations between
East and West and his job involved a great deal of travel, particularly
to Eastern European countries, and broadcasting.
He was a regular on BBC's Question time, sitting at the table with Sir
Robin Day. He is a Burns expert and holds a Burns supper each year when
he crams about 70 people into his Woodlands flat in the west end of
Glasgow. He plays the guitar and sings.
For two years he wrote a folk and trad music column for the New
Statesman and he has also done folk concert crits for the Glasgow
Herald. Back in Scotland he worked as a researcher for producer Gordon
Menzies with BBC Scotland TV and then became a radio reporter and
producer. He worked on a Channel 4 programme, I Shall Not Die But Live,
about the Wee Frees in the Outer Hebrides and says: ''At first they were
puzzled about somebody with a name like O'Rourke. What was this Tim
doing there? But we ended up the best of friends. My mother comes from
County Antrim which has given me a great interest in Irish music and
poetry.'' Strong rumour has it that O'Rourke and the NB team will be
taking on STV's next Hogmanay programme, another high risk area if ever
there was one.
Somehow he also finds time to tutor for the Continuing Education
Department of Glasgow University. His subjects so far have been modern
Irish poetry; Scottish and American detective fiction; song lyrics, from
Cole Porter to Bob Dylan; and this year's subject: the television image
in Scotland.
They started NB in April last year and are now into the fifth series.
Between times they have done NB specials, like the one on Glasgow Fair
that will launch the sixth series in July. NB has been rewarded with a
new prime time, early evening slot each Thursday. They might just get
out of the car park and into the building before the bells and the end
of 1990.
Why are you making commenting on The Herald only available to subscribers?
It should have been a safe space for informed debate, somewhere for readers to discuss issues around the biggest stories of the day, but all too often the below the line comments on most websites have become bogged down by off-topic discussions and abuse.
heraldscotland.com is tackling this problem by allowing only subscribers to comment.
We are doing this to improve the experience for our loyal readers and we believe it will reduce the ability of trolls and troublemakers, who occasionally find their way onto our site, to abuse our journalists and readers. We also hope it will help the comments section fulfil its promise as a part of Scotland's conversation with itself.
We are lucky at The Herald. We are read by an informed, educated readership who can add their knowledge and insights to our stories.
That is invaluable.
We are making the subscriber-only change to support our valued readers, who tell us they don't want the site cluttered up with irrelevant comments, untruths and abuse.
In the past, the journalist’s job was to collect and distribute information to the audience. Technology means that readers can shape a discussion. We look forward to hearing from you on heraldscotland.com
Comments & Moderation
Readers’ comments: You are personally liable for the content of any comments you upload to this website, so please act responsibly. We do not pre-moderate or monitor readers’ comments appearing on our websites, but we do post-moderate in response to complaints we receive or otherwise when a potential problem comes to our attention. You can make a complaint by using the ‘report this post’ link . We may then apply our discretion under the user terms to amend or delete comments.
Post moderation is undertaken full-time 9am-6pm on weekdays, and on a part-time basis outwith those hours.
Read the rules hereComments are closed on this article